- Kate DiCamillo - Because of Winn-Dixie (2001, Honor Book), The Tale of Despereaux (2004), Flora and Ulysses (2014)
- E.L. Konigsburg - Jennifer, Hecate, Macbeth, William McKinley, and Me, Elizabeth (1968, Honor Book), From the Mixed-Up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler (1968), The View from Saturday (1997)
- Joseph Krumgold - ...And Now Miguel (1954), Onion John (1960)
- Lois Lowry - Number the Stars (1990), The Giver (1994)
- Katherine Paterson - Bridge to Terebithia (1978), The Great Gilly Hopkins (1979, Honor Book), Jacob Have I Loved (1981)
- Elizabeth George Speare - The Witch of Blackbird Pond (1959), The Bronze Bow (1962), The Sign of the Beaver (1984, Honor Book)
One Newbery Medal and One or More Honor Books
- Lloyd Alexander - The Black Cauldron (Honor, 1966), The High King (Medal, 1969)
- Avi - The True Confessions of Charolotte Doyle (Honor, 1991), Nothing But the Truth (Honor, 1992), Crispin: The Cross of Lead (Medal, 2003)
- Beverly Cleary - Ramona and her Father (Honor, 1978), Ramona Quimby, Age 8 (Honor, 1982), Dear Mr. Henshaw (Medal, 1984)
- Susan Cooper - The Dark is Rising (Honor, 1974), The Grey King (Medal, 1976)
- Sharon Creech - Walk Two Moons (Medal, 1995), The Wanderer (Honor, 2001)
- Christopher Paul Curtis - The Watsons Go to Birmingham: 1963 (Honor, 1996), Bud, Not Buddy (Medal, 2000), Elijah of Buxton (Honor, 2008)
- Karen Cushman - Catherine, Called Birdy (Honor, 1995), The Midwife's Apprentice (Medal, 1996)
- Marguerite de Angeli - The Door in the Wall (Medal, 1950), Black Fox of Lorne (Honor, 1957)
- Eleanor Estes - The Middle Moffat (Honor, 1943), Rubus M. (Honor, 1944), The Hundred Dresses (Honor, 1945), Ginger Pye (Meda, 1952)
- Elizabeth Enright - Thimble Summer (Medal, 1939), Gone-Away Lake (Honor, 1958)
- Rachel Field - Hitty, Her First Hundred Years (Medal, 1930), Calico Bush (Honor, 1932)
- Paul Fleischman - Graven Images (Honor, 1983), Joyful Noise (Medal, 1989)
- Paula Fox - The Slave Dancer (Medal, 1974), One-Eyed Cat (Honor, 1985)
- Russell Freedman - Lincoln: A Photobiography (Medal, 1988), The Wright Brothers (Honor, 1992), Eleanor Roosevelt: A Life of Discovery (Honor, 1994)
- Charles Hawes - The Great Quest (Honor, 1922), The Dark Frigate (Medal, 1924)
- Jack Gantos - Joey Pigza Loses Control (Honor, 2001), Dead End in Norvelt (Medal, 2012)
- Jean Craighead George - My Side of the Mountain (Honor, 1960), Julie of the Wolves (Medal, 1973)
- Elizabeth Janet Gray - Meggy MacIntosh (Honor, 1931), Young Walter Scott (Honor, 1936), Penn (Honor, 1939), Adam of the Road (Medal, 1943)
- Virginia Hamilton - The Planet of Junior Brown (Honor, 1972), M.C. Higgins, the Great (Medal, 1975), Sweet Whispers, Brother Rush (Honor, 1983), In the Beginning: Creation Stories from Around the World (Honor, 1989)
- Marguerite Henry - Justin Morgan Had a Horse (Honor, 1946), Misty of Chincoteague (Honor, 1948), King of the Wind (Medal, 1949)
- Irene Hunt - Across Five Aprils (Honor, 1965), Up a Road Slowly (Medal, 1967)
- Robert Lawson - Rabbit Hill (Medal, 1945), The Great Wheel (Honor, 1958)
- Lois Lenski - Phebe Fairchild: Her Book (Honor, 1937), Indian Captive: The Story of Mary Jemison (Honor, 1942), Strawberry Girl (Medal, 1946)
- Robin McKinley - The Blue Sword (Honor, 1983), The Hero and the Crown (Medal, 1985)
- Cornelia Meigs - The Windy Hill (Honor, 1922), Clearing Weather (Honor, 1929), Swift Rivers (Honor, 1933), Invincible Louisa: The Story of the Author of Little Women (Medal, 1934)
- Scott O'Dell - Island of the Blue Dolphins (Medal, 1961), The King's Fifth (Honor, 1967), The Black Pearl (Honor, 1968), Sing Down the Moon (Honor, 1971)
- Gary Paulsen - Dogsong (1986), Hatchet (1988), The Winter Room (1990)
- Richard Peck - A Long Way from Chicago (Honor, 1999), A Year Down Yonder (Medal 2001)
- Ellen Raskin - Figgs & Phantoms (Honor, 1975), The Westing Game (Medal, 1979)
- Cynthia Rylant - A Fine White Dust (Honor, 1987), Missing May (Medal, 1993)
- Laura Amy Schlitz - Good Masters! Sweet Ladies! Voices from a Medieval Village (Medal, 2008), Splendors and Glooms (Honor, 2013)
- Kate Seredy - The Good Master (Honor, 1936), The White Stag (Medal, 1938), The Singing Tree (Honor, 1940)
- Armstrong Sperry - All Sail Set: A Romance of the Flying Cloud (Honor, 1936), Call it Courage (Medal, 1941)
- Jerry Spinelli - Maniac Magee (Medal, 1991), Wringer (Honor, 1998)
- Cynthia Voigt - Dicey's Song (Medal, 1983), A Solitary Blue (Honor, 1984)
- Elizabeth Yates - Mountain Born (Honor, 1944), Amos Fortune, Free Man (1951)
Multiple Honor Books but never the Newbery Medal
- Julia Davis Adams - Vaino (1930), Mountains are Free (1931)
- Claire Huchet Bishop - Pancakes-Paris (1948), All Alone (1954)
- Bruce Brooks - The Moves Make the Man (1985), What Hearts (1993)
- Mary & Conrad Buff - Big Tree (1947), The Apple and the Arrow (1952), Magic Maize (1954)
- Padraic Colum - The Golden Fleece and the Heroes Who Lived Before Achilles (1922), The Voyagers: Being Legends and Romances of Atlantic Discovery (1926), Big Tree of Bunlahy: Stories of My Own Countryside (1934)
- Alice Dalgliesh - The Silver Pencil (1945), The Bears on Hemlock Mountain (1953), Courage of Sarah Noble (1955)
- Meindert DeJong - Shadrach (1954), Hurry Home, Candy (1954), The Wheel of the School (1955), The House of Sixty Fathers (1957), Along Came a Dog (1959)
- Jeanette Eaton - A Daughter of the Seine: The Life of Madame Roland (1930), Leader by Destiny: George Washington, Man and Patriot (1939), Lone Journey: The Life of Roger Williams (1945), Gandhi, Fighter Without a Sword (1951)
- Nancy Farmer - The Ear, the Eye and the Arm (1995), A Girl Named Disaster (1997), The House of the Scorpion (2003)
- Genevieve Foster - George Washington's World (1942), Abraham Lincoln's World (1945), George Washington (1950), Birthdays of Freedom, Vol. 1 (1953)
- Wanda Gag - Millions of Cats (1929), ABC Bunny (1934)
- Patricia Reilly Giff - Lily's Crossing (1998), Pictures of Hollis Woods (2003)
- Kevin Henkes - Olive's Ocean (2004), The Year of Billy Miller (2014)
- Agnes Hewes - Spice and the Devil's Cave (1931), Glory of the Seas (1934), The Codfish Musket (1937)
- Holling C. Holling - Seabird (1949), Minn of the Mississippi (1952)
- Jennifer L. Holm - Our Only May Amelia (2000), Penny from Heaven (2007), Turtle in Paradise (2011)
- Mabel Leigh Hunt - Have You Seen Tom Thumb? (1943), Better Known as Johnny Appleseed (1951)
- Gerald W. Johnson - America is Born: A History for Peter (1960), America Moves Forward: A History for Peter (1961)
- Clara Ingram Judson - Abraham Lincoln, Friend of the People (1951), Theodore Roosevelt, Fighting Patriot (1954), Mr. Justice Holmes (1957),
- Eloise Jarvis McGraw - Moccasin Trail (1953), The Golden Goblet (1962), The Moorchild (1997)
- Jim Murphy - The Great Fire (1996), An American Plague (2004)
- Walter Dean Myers - Scorpions (1989), Somewhere in the Darkness (1993)
- Anne Parrish - The Dream Coach (1925), Floating Island (1931), The Story of Appleby Capple (1951)
- Mabel Robinson - Bright Island (1938), Running of the Mountain Tops: The Life of Louis Agassiz (1940)
- Constance Rourke - Davy Crockett (1935), Audubon (1937)
- Julia Sauer - Fog Magic (1944), The Light at Tern Rock (1952)
- Gary D. Schmidt - Lizzie Bright and the Buckminster Boy (2005), The Wednesday Wars (2008)
- Katherine Shippen - New Found World (1946), Men, Microscopes and Living Things (1956)
- Isaac Bashevis Singer - Zlateh The Goat and Other Stories (1967), The Fearsome Inn (1968), When Shlemiel Went to Warsaw and Other Stories (1969)
- Caroline Snedeker - Downright Dencey (1928), The Forgotten Daughter (1934)
- Zilpha Keatley Snyder - The Egypt Game (1968), The Headless Cupid (1972), The Witches of Worm (1973)
- William Steig - Abel's Island (1977), Doctor DeSoto (1983)
- Mary Stolz - Belling the Tiger (1962), The Noonday Friends (1966)
- Hildegarde Swift - Little Blacknose (1930), The Railroad to Freedom: A Story of the Civil War (1933)
- Laura Ingalls Wilder - On the Banks of Plum Creek (1938), By the Shores of Silver Lake (1940), The Long Winter (1941), Little Town on the Prairie (1942), These Happy Golden Years (1944)
- Jacqueline Woodson - Show Way (2006), Feathers (2008), After Tupac & D Foster (2009), Brown Girl Dreaming (2014)
- Laurence Yep - Dragonwings (1976), Dragon's Gate (1994)
- Ella Young - The Wonder Smith and His Son (1928), The Tangle-Coated Horse and Other Tales (1930)
