#2 - Cathrine Called Birdy

Catherine Called Birdy
Karen Cushman
1995 Newbery Honor Book
Historical Fiction

I remember reading this book in sixth grade because my teacher had a copy in the classroom.  I must have been out of books to read or needing something for Accelerated Reader because at the time, I almost exclusively read Star Trek books.  I remember having to stifle my laughs in class.

This book is told in a series of journal entries that Catherine makes as she goes her through her daily life as the daughter of a knight.  Eventually, she gets a book of saints so the saint of the day is added to the entries.  Catherine wants to do so much more than just do embroidery but she gets even more upset when she finds out that she is getting married off to Shaggy Beard, an old man. 

Unfortunately, this book gets a lot of flack because many argue that a girl in the middle ages would not be able to read and write.  While that is probably very true, I am sure that there were some exceptions to the rule.  Moreover, I tend to suspend my disbelief when reading so a lot of the inaccuracies don't always bother me.

I liked this book a lot better than The Midwife's Apprentice which actually won Cushman the Newbery medal.  They are both set in the middle ages but this book is way more detailed. 

Newbery 1971

Summer of the Swans
Author: Betsy Byars
Genre: Realistic Fiction
Plot: Sara and her family search for Charlie, who is lost.
Verdict: Underwhelming
My rating: 3 stars


Knee Knock Rise
Author: Natalie Babbitt
Genre: Fantasy
Plot: Egan travels to Instep where the people live in fear of Kneeknock Rise.
Verdict: A bit odd
My rating: 2 stars


Enchantress From the Stars
Author: Sylvia Louise Engdahl
Genre: Science Fiction
Plot: A group of aliens must pretend to be mystics to help a primitive planet.
Verdict: The narrator rambles a lot
My rating: 3 stars


Sing Down the Moon
Author: Scott O'Dell
Genre: Historical Fiction
Plot: A Native American Girl is kidnapped and forced to walk the Navaho Long Walk.
Verdict: The history draws you in
My rating: 3 stars

This year was an odd mix of genres that starts normal and gets odder as we travel down the list.  Sadly, none of these books really caught my undivided attention.  We start with Summer of the Swans which is a realistic fiction book.  The characters are children who are living with their aunt and not enjoying their summer.  Things heat up, when one of the children wanders off and becomes lost.  This is especially worrying because he is intellectually disabled.  I originally thought that he was Autistic but it comes out in the book that he became brain-damaged as a result of a fever. 

The next book is Kneeknock Rise by Natalie Babbitt.  Babbitt is famous for her book Tuck Everlasting which everyone assumes won the Newbery honor, when in fact her book that graced the Newbery list is Kneeknock Rise.  The two books are similar in that they are almost realistic fiction but have a small element of fantasy.  This book is about a boy named Egan who travels to Instep to go to a fair.  Instep is in the shadow of Kneeknock Rise, where a monster is supposed to dwell so the whole town in afraid of it.  The book explores his interaction with this forbidden place (I won't give away any spoilers).

If that wasn't strange enough, we move onto Enchantress From the Stars.  I think I might have liked this book a little better if I hadn't listened to the audio version.  The narrator tends to go off on tangents and wander a bit and this is made very evident when you hear it read aloud.  The plot is also extremely science fiction (in fact, the author says that it's really for an older audience but keeps getting read to younger audiences because of its Newbery status).  The basic premise is that a group of aliens find themselves on a primitive world where they have to help the native primitive aliens evict another group of aliens who are trying to terraform and colonize the planet (which will kill the natives) but they can't give themselves away to either group of aliens because both of them are less advanced.  So, the aliens have to pass themselves off a wizards (or, specifically, an enchantress) and get some of the native aliens to use "magic" (advanced technology) to run off the invading aliens.  If it sounds confusing, that's because it is.  Apparently, there are even more books written in the series after this one.  It would be a good choice to snag juvenile science fiction lovers.

The last book returns to normal with Sing Down the Moon.  Scott O'Dell is no stranger to the Newbery list (with a medal for The Island of the Blue Dolphins and several honors).  This book is about a Native American girl who gets forced to join the Navaho Long Walk where the Natives were relocated against their will.  His writing is excellent and I enjoyed it.

#3 - The House of the Scorpion

The House of the Scorpion
Nancy Farmer
2003 Newbery Honor Book
Science Fiction

I don't remember if this was the first Nancy Farmer book I read or if it was The Ear, The Eye and The Arm (1995 Newbery Honor Book).  In any case, between those two books, Nancy Farmer quickly became one of my favorite authors.

This book is a science fiction novel that rides the line between children's lit and YA.  It is set in futuristic, post apocalyptic Mexico.  We are introduced to Matteo, a young boy living on an opium plantation.  After an accident, Matteo is sent to live at the big house where we discover that he is not a normal boy, but a clone of the drug lord, El Patron.  Matteo soon finds that there a people who see clones as fellow humans, and those who see clones as nothing but animals.

The book explores some controversial themes such as are clones actual people?  Do they have rights?  Can they be grown for replacement parts?  There is a sequel to this book (The Lord of Opium) but I did not like it as much as I did the original. 

Newbery 2017

The Girl Who Drank the Moon
Author: Kelly Barnhill
Genre: Fantasy
Plot: Xan rescues a girl but accidentally feeds her moonlight, causing the girl to become magical.
Verdict: Great plot twists
My rating: 4 stars


Wolf Hollow
Author: Lauren Wolk
Genre: Historical Fiction
Plot: A girl who is bullying Annebelle makes trouble for the town, specifically for a war veteran named Toby.
Verdict: Interesting look at a bully
My rating: 3 stars


The Inquisitor's Tale
Author: Adam Gidwitz
Genre: Fantasy
Plot: In a tavern, the tale of three magical children is pieced together.
Verdict: Odd ending
My rating: 3 stars


Freedom Over Me
Author: Ashley Bryan
Genre: Poetry
Plot: A set of poems of the profiles of slaves at a slave auction.
Verdict: Potent and thought-provoking
My rating: 4 stars

This year in Newbery was a very interesting year.  I enjoyed the winner, The Girl Who Drank the Moon.  It is a high fantasy about a girl who is fed moonlight on accident by a witch, who then is forced to raise her because of her potential magical powers.  The other fantasy offering of the year was The Inquisitor's Tale.  I read this book first because it looked the most interesting with its great illuminations.  It was a interesting because the story is pieced together by people in a tavern which gives it a unique story telling experience, however, I was not thrilled with the ending.

The other two books are more historical ficotion.  Wolf  Hollow was set during World War II.  It involves a girl named Annabelle and her family as well as a veteran named Toby, who lives alone on the outskirts of town.  Annabelle is bullied by a girl in town and Toby becomes involved as the girl tells lies about an incident that happens.  Freedom Over Me is a collection of poems but it also historical fiction.  The author takes a bill of sale for a slave auction and creates backstories for all the different slaves who are on the auction block.  The mixing of the poetry and his art creates a very powerful book which should be a part of any Civil War unit.  If you look up Ashley Bryan, you will find that he has a very long and illustrious career.