Saturday, February 13, 2016
Newbery 1974
The Slave Dancer
Author: Paula Fox
Genre: Historical Fiction
Plot: Jessie is kidnapped and pressed into service on a slave ship.
Verdict: Interesting story, choppy writing
My rating: 2 stars
The Dark is Rising
Author: Susan Cooper
Genre: Fantasy
Plot: Will discovers that he is one of the "old ones" and must collect 6 signs.
Verdict: Confusing at start but gets better
My rating: 3 stars
Both books from this year are pretty dark. The first, The Slave Dancer, is an historical fiction book about a boy pressed into service on a slave ship. I'm not sure his kidnapping is plausible but the horrible conditions on the slave ship certainly are. He is a first hand witness to the horrors of slavery. The second book, The Dark is Rising, is the second book of the series, also titled "The Dark is Rising." It does not seem to be unusual for the second book in a series to get honored on the Newbery list (The Black Cauldron, The Tombs of Atuan and Dicey's Song come to mind) and usually, I recommend that that reader read the first book or books in a series leading up the one who has won and award. In this case, the book is only slightly connected to the first book so it is not necessary to read the first book. However, the fourth book in the series, The Gray King, is a medal winner so if you are trying to read the Newbery list, you might as well read the whole series. The Dark is Rising is a darker low fantasy book about a boy named Will who finds out he is an "Old One" and has special powers.
Newbery 1996
The Midwife's Apprentice
Author: Karen Cushman
Genre: Historical Fiction
Plot: Brat learns to be an apprentice to a midwife.
Verdict: Not quite as good as Catherine
My rating: 4 stars
What Jamie Saw
Author: Carolyn Coman
Genre: Realistic Fiction
Plot: Jamie, his mother and his sister flee their mother's abusive significant other.
Verdict: A bit dark
My rating: 2 stars
The Watsons Go to Birmingham - 1963
Author: Christopher Paul Curtis
Genre: Historical Fiction
Plot: The Watson family travels to Birmingham to drop off their oldest son, Byron.
Verdict: The first chapter is great
My rating: 3 stars
Yolanda's Genius
Author: Carol Fenner
Genre: Realistic Fiction
Plot: Yolanda discovers that her brother is a harmonica prodigy.
Verdict: Interesting story
My rating: 3 stars
The Great Fire
Author: Jim Murphy
Genre: Nonfiction
Plot: The story of the great Chicago fire.
Verdict: Great descriptions
My rating: 3 stars
The winner of the medal this year was The Midwife's Apprentice by Karen Cushman, who won an honor the previous year for Catherine Called Birdy. I felt that Catherine was actually a better book but it was up against some stiff competition. The Midwife's Apprentice is a great book about an urchin girl who becomes an apprentice to the local midwife and is frustrated when she feels she isn't learning anything.
I felt that fiction honor books were a bit lackluster this year. The Watsons Go to Birmingham was the best. I was not impressed with What Jamie Saw. Yolanda's Genius was a little better.
On the other hand, the nonfiction book for the year, The Great Fire was excellent. It described in detail the events of the great Chicago fire, including diagrams to show the path of the fire as it spread. It also talked about the "fire proof building" and how they still had weaknesses that led to them burning as well.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)